

Two Propositions that Shape Onteora's Future —
With No Increase in the Tax Levy
The revised path toward making capital improvements to Onteora’s Central Campus recognizes the public’s desire for a lower overall price and the high priority goal of keeping K-5 students together for academic, social, and emotional benefits. Two propositions were developed because the community asked to keep the expansion of Bennett Elementary to a Grades K-5 school separate from the Boiceville campus’ “nuts and bolts” infrastructure updates.
The work proposed in both can still be completed with no increase in the tax levy.
What does each proposition mean for Onteora’s future?
Proposition 1 Create a Districtwide K-5 Elementary School adds classrooms, updates instructional spaces, and strengthens infrastructure at Bennett Elementary. The result of this proposition will determine whether Grade 5 will learn at Bennett or at the Middle School.
Proposition 2 K-12 Renovations and Infrastructure Upgrades includes the kinds of “nuts and bolts” projects that keep buildings in good operating condition and will set a foundation for the future.

These two propositions are independent of each other. The ballot includes "yes" or "no" on each proposition, and voters may vote for each.
FISCAL SUSTAINABILITY IS A CORE COMPONENT OF THIS REVISED PATH
Public input after the May 20 vote clearly called for a lower price tag. The revised plan costs 40% less than the original proposition and cuts borrowing in half.
What has not changed is the ability to complete the Capital Project described in both propositions with no increase in the tax levy.

What are the current conditions?
What’s possible with voter approval?
STRATEGIC FUNDING PLAN, NO TAX LEVY INCREASE
Here is the strategic funding plan for two separate propositions that give voters separate choices related to the future location for Grade 5 (Proposition 1) and to “nuts and bolts” infrastructure updates that are unrelated to Bennett expansion (Proposition 2).
Proposition 1 Funding
The $26.9 million bond (which is similar to a mortgage) to create a districtwide K-5 elementary school would be paid through a combination of State Aid and the savings generated through the efficiencies of a Central Campus.
- Projected annual bond payments: $2.4 million
- Projected annual State Aid revenue: $687,600
- Projected annual savings: $3.2 million
Bond payments and State Aid would remain stable throughout the 15-year bond term. The projected annual savings would yield additional savings each year after factoring in inflation. For instance, transportation costs will decrease in 2028 when all students attend schools in Boiceville. Transportation costs rise each year as inflation affects labor and fuel, so the amount saved through centralization will continue to grow.
These cost savings are especially important as we anticipate significant changes to the New York State Foundation Aid formula and a possible reduction in federal funding – either of which would reduce the District’s revenues. The project is structured to give us three years to proactively plan for bringing our students together on the Central Campus. The Board believes this approach is far preferable to being forced into a reactive response to the likely funding cuts.
Proposition 2 Funding
The $15 million cost for K-12 renovations and infrastructure upgrades would be paid with State Aid, our voter-approved Capital Reserve, and cash on hand. There is no need to borrow for these improvements, and therefore no need to pay interest or increase taxes.
- No borrowing needed
- Projected annual State Aid revenue: $402,000
ANNUAL SAVINGS AFTER DEBT PAYMENTS: $1.7M+
After bond payments for the borrowing for Proposition 1, the plan actually creates a net savings of more than $1.7 million a year. This savings provides a cushion to absorb future rising costs in other areas or reductions in Foundation Aid, serving to keep future tax increases lower than they otherwise would be.
Vote: Wednesday, December 10
New! In-Person Voting will be in the Wrestling Room at the Middle/High School in Boiceville from 7 AM to 9 PM.
Early Mail Ballots Available! If you’d like to vote early, skip the line on vote day, or skip the trip to Boiceville, just complete and return an Early Mail Ballot application. Once you receive your ballot, you can either:
- Mail it back to us.
- Deliver it to the new secure ballot box at Woodstock Elementary on December 10 between 7 AM–5 PM.
- Drop it off to the District Clerk in person by 5 PM on December 10.
Learn more, see deadlines, and download your application here.
COMMUNITY PRESENTATION
JOIN US on December 2 from 6 to 7 PM at the Middle/High School Cafeteria for a visual presentation with project images, an overview of the plans, and time for community questions.
We'll also be at public meetings (many are still being confirmed) to share information in the coming weeks, including:
- Nov. 13 at 6 PM - Woodstock PTA Meeting
- Nov. 15 from 10 AM - 12 PM at Phoenicia Library
- Nov. 17 at 6 PM - Booster Club Meeting at Boiceville Inn
- Nov. 20 from 6:30-9:30 PM - at the Olive Free Library for the Catskill Mountain String Band
- Dec. 9 at 7 PM - Olive Town Board Meeting
JUST ANNOUNCED:
On Nov. 15 members of the Board will be at Phoenicia Library from 10 AM to Noon to help people understand the Early Mail Ballot process or answer questions about the project. Stop by!
MISSION: Our Onteora schools exist to educate and nurture the children of our diverse community. Our mission is to create an engaging and healthy learning environment that empowers all students to pursue their dreams, achieve their goals, and contribute thoughtfully to the global community.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Will this project raise taxes?
- How can the District afford this without raising taxes?
- How much were the costs and borrowing reduced from the original proposal?
- How does the plan benefit students?
- How does the plan benefit the community?
- What happens if the propositions are not approved?
- Will rejecting Proposition 1 prevent the closure of Woodstock Elementary School?
- How will Onteora successfully transition to a Central Campus?
- What is the timeline for construction if the propositions pass?
- What will happen to the Woodstock building when it closes?
- Why is there only one polling location?
- How can residents vote early or by mail?
Will this project raise taxes?
How can the District afford this without raising taxes?
How much were the costs and borrowing reduced from the original proposal?
How does the plan benefit students?
How does the plan benefit the community?
What happens if the propositions are not approved?
Will rejecting Proposition 1 prevent the closure of Woodstock Elementary School?
How will Onteora successfully transition to a Central Campus?
What is the timeline for construction if the propositions pass?
What will happen to the Woodstock building when it closes?
Why is there only one polling location?
How can residents vote early or by mail?
Historical Background
The Board of Education unanimously made the difficult decision to close Woodstock Elementary at the end of the 2027-2028 academic year, establishing Boiceville as a K-12 Central Campus with the start of the 2028-29 year.
You can review the history of this decision, information about the unsuccessful May project, and other details that informed this decision and the decision for the work identified in this Capital Project proposal found here.
OUR COMMITMENTS:
We will work hard to explain the propositions to voters and to ensure a smooth and robust voting process on December 10.
We will show up alongside the community to honor and celebrate the heritage of Woodstock Elementary School and support students, teachers, staff, and families through this transition.
We will remain steadfast to our mission.
We will be thoughtful about how to adapt closed schools in partnership with the community.
With community guidance, we will keep in mind a “Future Phase” of improvements that could happen at some point in the District’s future.
We will continue communicating with the Onteora community as we refine plans and determine the schedule for construction and renovations.




















